Pit Composting Step by Step: Your Genius Essential Guide
Tired of tossing those kitchen scraps and yard waste into the trash? Wish you could turn them into rich, healthy soil for your garden? You can! Pit composting is a wonderfully simple way to recycle organic materials and boost your garden’s goodness. It might sound complicated, but I’m here to show you it’s totally doable. Let’s dig in and get your compost pile going!
What Exactly is Pit Composting?
Pit composting, also known as heap composting or undertrench composting, is one of the oldest and easiest composting methods around. Simply put, it involves burying your organic waste directly into the ground. Unlike building a fancy bin or a multi-layered tumbler, this method is all about digging a hole, filling it with your compostable materials, and letting nature do its magic underground.
Why Choose Pit Composting?
As your friendly guide from TopChooser, I love solutions that are effective, affordable, and straightforward. Pit composting checks all those boxes and then some!
The Big Wins of Pit Composting:
- Super Simple to Start: No need for fancy bins or equipment. Just your shovel and your scraps.
- Cost-Effective: It’s practically free! You’re using what you already have and a bit of your garden space.
- Less Odor & Pests: Burying the materials helps keep smells to a minimum and deters unwanted garden visitors.
- Moisture Retention: The surrounding soil helps keep your compost heap moist, which is crucial for decomposition.
- Nutrient Leaching: As water passes through, it carries valuable nutrients down into the soil, feeding your plants and soil microbes.
- Space-Saving: If you have a yard, you have space! It doesn’t take up extra room in your garden layout.
What Can You Compost (and What Should You Avoid)?
Knowing what goes into your compost pit is key to creating that nutrient-rich soil. Think of it as feeding your compost pile a balanced diet. You’ll want to mix your “greens” and “browns” for the best results.
The “Greens” (Nitrogen-Rich):
These are typically wet materials that provide nitrogen, essential for heating up the compost pile.
- Fruit and vegetable scraps (peels, cores, uneaten portions)
- Coffee grounds and tea bags
- Grass clippings (in moderation)
- Plant trimmings (young, non-woody parts)
- Manure from herbivores (chickens, rabbits, cows, horses – aged is best)
The “Browns” (Carbon-Rich):
These are dry, woody materials that provide carbon, helping to balance the greens and allow air circulation.
- Dry leaves
- Straw and hay
- Shredded newspaper and cardboard (avoid glossy paper and colored ink)
- Small twigs and wood chips
- Sawdust (from untreated wood only)
- Eggshells (crushed)
What to Leave Out:
Some things are best kept out of your compost pit to avoid attracting pests, spreading diseases, or creating unpleasant odors.
- Meat, fish, and bones (attract pests)
- Dairy products (attract pests, can smell)
- Oily or greasy foods
- Diseased plants or weeds that have gone to seed (unless you’re very confident in your pile’s heat)
- Pet waste (dog and cat feces can contain pathogens)
- Treated wood or sawdust from treated wood
- Coal ash or charcoal briquettes
- Synthetic materials (plastics, metals, glass)
Getting Started: Your Pit Composting Checklist
Ready to roll up your sleeves? Here’s a simple rundown of what you’ll need before you start digging.
Essential Tools:
- Shovel or Spade: Your trusty digging tool.
- Garden Fork: Handy for turning and aerating the compost later on.
- Watering Can or Hose: To keep things moist.
- Kitchen Scraps Caddy: A small container to collect waste indoors before taking it out.
Choosing Your Pit Location:
This is a crucial step for success. Pick a spot that’s:
- Accessible: Easy to reach from your kitchen and garden.
- Well-Drained: Avoid areas that tend to get waterlogged after rain.
- Partially Shaded: Too much direct sun can dry out your compost too quickly, while full shade might keep it too cool and slow decomposition.
- Away from Water Sources: Keep it a safe distance from wells or natural water bodies.
- Not Directly Under Tree Roots: You don’t want competing roots stealing moisture and nutrients.
Pit Composting Step-by-Step: Your Easy Guide
Let’s get composting! This process is designed for beginners, so don’t worry if you’ve never done this before. Follow these simple steps.
-
Step 1: Dig Your Pit
Choose a spot in your yard that meets the criteria we just discussed. Using your shovel, dig a pit that’s roughly 2-3 feet deep, 3 feet wide, and 3 feet long. The size can vary depending on your available space and how much compostable material you generate. You can make it shallower and wider or deeper and narrower if that suits your needs better. The key is to create an underground space for your compost.
-
Step 2: Add Your First Layer
Start by laying down a base layer of coarse “brown” materials. Think small twigs, straw, or wood chips. This helps with drainage and aeration at the bottom of the pit, preventing it from becoming a soggy mess. This initial layer should be about 4-6 inches thick.
-
Step 3: Start Adding Greens and Browns
Begin adding your kitchen scraps (“greens”) and other organic materials (“browns”). Aim for a mix. A good rule of thumb is to try and maintain a ratio of about 2-3 parts brown material to 1 part green material. So, for every bucket of kitchen scraps you add, try to add two or three buckets of dry leaves, shredded paper, or straw. This balance is crucial for efficient decomposition. Don’t worry about precise measurements; just aim for a good mix.
-
Step 4: Bury Your Waste
This is the “pit” part! After adding a layer of greens and browns, cover them with a few inches of soil. This soil acts as a natural lid, helping to insulate the compost, retain moisture, and deter pests and odors. You can even use a layer of brown material like straw or leaves as a final cover if you don’t have enough soil readily available.
-
Step 5: Keep it Moist
Your compost pile needs moisture to break down effectively. It should feel like a wrung-out sponge – damp, but not soaking wet. If it starts to look dry, give it a good watering with your watering can or hose. Rain will often keep it adequately moist, but it’s good to check, especially during dry spells. Overwatering can lead to a smelly, anaerobic (oxygen-deprived) condition, so be mindful.
For more on maintaining ideal moisture levels, the EPA’s composting guide offers excellent general principles applicable even to pit composting.
-
Step 6: Continue Adding Materials
As you continue to generate kitchen scraps and yard waste, simply dig a small hole within the existing pit, add your materials, and cover them with soil or brown matter. You can keep adding to the same pit until it’s full, or you can start a second one nearby once the first is substantially filled. The decomposition process happens continuously.
-
Step 7: Allow Time for Composting
This is where patience comes in. The decomposition process takes time. Depending on factors like the mix of materials, moisture, and temperature, it can take anywhere from a few months to a year or more for the materials at the bottom of the pit to fully break down into rich, dark compost.
-
Step 8: Harvesting Your Compost
Once the material at the bottom looks like dark, crumbly soil and no longer resembles the original scraps, it’s ready to use! You can carefully dig down to the bottom of the pit and scoop out the finished compost. It’s a good idea to leave any larger, undecomposed bits behind to continue breaking down, or simply sift them out and toss them back into the working compost.
A Quick Comparison: Pit Composting vs. Other Methods
To help you see where pit composting shines, let’s quickly glance at how it stacks up against other popular composting methods. As your guide at TopChooser, I aim to give you the full picture!
Feature | Pit Composting | Bin Composting (Enclosed/Tumbling) | Open Piling |
---|---|---|---|
Ease of Setup | Very Easy (Dig a hole) | Moderate to Difficult (Assemble bin) | Easy (Pile it up outside) |
Cost | Free | Moderate to High (Cost of bin) | Free |
Odor Control | Excellent (Buried materials) | Good to Excellent (Enclosed) | Fair to Poor (Can attract pests) |
Pest Attraction | Very Low (Buried) | Low to Moderate (Depends on bin design) | High (Uncovered materials) |
Moisture Control | Good (Soil buffers) | Good (Bin helps retain moisture) | Poor to Fair (Dries out easily) |
Space Required | Subterranean (takes garden space) | Surface (takes garden space) | Surface (takes garden space) |
Decomposition Speed | Moderate to Slow (depends on conditions) | Fastest (if managed well, especially tumblers) | Moderate to Slow |
Nutrient Leaching | Low (potential for soil enrichment directly below) | Moderate (can happen with overwatering) | High (nutrients wash away with rain) |
Troubleshooting Common Pit Composting Issues
Even the simplest methods can have a hiccup or two. Here are some common issues and how to fix them, keeping things practical and stress-free.
Issue: My Compost Smells Bad.
Why it happens: Usually, it’s too wet or lacks air (anaerobic), or you have too many “greens” (nitrogen). A strong ammonia smell means too much nitrogen; a rotten egg smell means it’s too wet and not getting enough air.
The Fix:
- Add more “brown” materials like dry leaves, shredded cardboard, or straw to absorb excess moisture and balance the nitrogen.
- Gently turn or aerate the top layer if possible, without disturbing the actively decomposing middle and bottom too much.
- Ensure you’re burying your waste properly with soil or brown cover.
Issue: Nothing Seems to Be Happening (Decomposition is Slow).
Why it happens: The compost pile might be too dry, too cold, or lack enough of the right ingredients (greens and browns). Small compostable particles decompose faster than large ones.
The Fix:
- Check for moisture. If it’s dry, water it.
- Make sure you have a good mix of greens and browns. If it’s all browns, add more kitchen scraps. If it’s all greens, add more dry leaves or cardboard.
- Chop or shred larger items like vegetable stalks or cardboard into smaller pieces. This increases surface area for microbes to work on.
- If it’s very cold outside, decomposition will naturally slow down. It will pick up again as temperatures rise.
Issue: I’m Seeing Pests (Flies, Rodents).
Why it happens: This is usually due to exposed food scraps or including items that attract pests (like meat or dairy).
The Fix:
- Always ensure your waste is well-covered with soil or a thick layer of brown material.
- Avoid adding meat, fish, bones, dairy, or greasy foods to your pit compost.
- If you’re using a kitchen caddy, make sure it’s sealed tightly when stored indoors.
The “Why Not” Section: When Pit Composting Might Not Be Ideal
While pit composting is fantastic for many situations, I always like to be upfront about when a method might not be the best fit. For instance, if you’re in a very small apartment with no yard space, this method won’t work. Similarly, if you have extremely poor soil drainage and your chosen spot becomes waterlogged regularly, you might face challenges with decomposition.
Also, if you’re looking for compost super quickly, like in a matter of weeks, managed bin systems (especially tumblers) can often be faster. Pit composting relies a bit more on ambient conditions and takes its sweet time. However, for reliability and ease, it’s hard to beat for long-term composting.
FAQs: Your Quick Pit Composting Answers
Q1: How deep should a pit compost hole be?
A1: A good starting depth is 2 to 3 feet. This allows for enough material and helps insulate the compost pile.
Q2: Can I put my pit compost anywhere in my yard?
A2: It’s best to pick a spot that’s accessible, well-drained, and has some shade but isn’t completely waterlogged or in constant, direct sun.
Q3: How often do I need to turn pit compost?
A3: Unlike traditional piles, pit compost generally doesn’t require regular turning. The soil cover naturally helps with aeration and moisture management. You mainly interact when adding new scraps.
Q4: What if my pit compost pile gets too wet?
A4: Add more dry brown materials like leaves, straw, or shredded paper to absorb excess moisture. Ensure the pit is located in a well-drained area.
Q5: How do I know when my pit compost is ready to use?
A5: It’s ready when the material at the bottom looks like dark, crumbly soil, smells earthy, and no longer resembles the original kitchen scraps or yard waste.
Q6: Can I compost in a pit if I have a small garden?
A6: Yes! Even a small garden can accommodate a pit compost. You can adjust the size of the pit to fit your space and needs.
Conclusion: Start Composting Today with Confidence!
See? Pit composting is a super accessible way to transform your waste into garden gold. It’s forgiving, doesn’t need much attention, and it quietly works its magic underground. You’re not just reducing what goes to the landfill; you’re actively enriching your soil, making your plants happier, and contributing to a healthier environment. Grab that shovel, start gathering your greens and browns, and give pit composting a try. Your garden will thank you for it, and you’ll feel that great sense of accomplishment that comes from doing it yourself. Happy composting!

I am passionate about home engineering. I specialize in designing, installing, and maintaining heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems. My goal is to help people stay comfortable in their homes all year long.